OnlyFans vs. Fansly: Which Platform Is Better?

When we talk about subscription-based social media platforms where creators can earn big by sharing photos and videos, OnlyFans often springs to mind. It’s become almost as mainstream as a site featuring NSFW content can be, and is widely recognized.

Yet, OnlyFans isn’t without its flaws, and it’s certainly not the sole choice for creators seeking to branch out. There’s a plethora of alternatives offering more features or catering to specific niches.

Enter Fansly. Fansly may not have a unique niche, but it stands as one of the closest rivals to OnlyFans, with many similarities between them.

However, Fansly isn’t just sitting back. It’s actively expanding its features and striving to be a robust contender to OnlyFans, even though it’s somewhat playing catch-up with other platforms.

So, the big question: Fansly or OnlyFans? Which platform takes the crown? Keep reading as we dive deep into this face-off and help you make an informed choice.

onlyfans vs fansly 1

OnlyFans: A Pioneer in Subscriber-Based NSFW Content

Labeling a site launched in 2016 as ‘established’ might seem unusual, but in the realm of subscriber-based NSFW content, OnlyFans is undeniably a trailblazer. It’s amassed a vast array of creators, attracting millions of monthly visitors. While it positions itself as a platform for all kinds of creators, its biggest triumphs undeniably lie within the NSFW sector.

This background made it all the more shocking when OnlyFans announced in August 2021 a ban on sexual content. The reversal of this decision just days later was less surprising. But this episode left a lingering question about the platform’s future, especially for NSFW content creators. With aims to broaden its mainstream appeal, OnlyFans might revisit such changes in the future.

Interested in joining OnlyFans? Sign up [here].

Fansly: A Rising Competitor

Pinpointing the exact launch of Fansly is tricky, but it’s a relatively new player, emerging into the spotlight mostly after 2020. The platform really gained traction in 2021, especially amidst rumors of OnlyFans’ shift away from NSFW content, leading to a surge in new creator sign-ups on Fansly.

Fansly is often seen as a mirror of OnlyFans but comes with additional features that could tempt creators looking for something more. For those new to such platforms or considering a switch, Fansly’s unique offerings are worth exploring.

Read more: Fansly Review

fansly homepage
Fansly Homepage

OnlyFans Vs. Fansly

FeatureOnlyFansFanslyNotes
User ExperienceSimilar to FanslySimilar to OnlyFans, slightly betterBoth platforms are quite similar in user experience. Fansly is perceived as slightly more user-friendly.
Revenue ModelsSubscription fees, direct messages, tipsSubscription tiers, direct messages, tipsFansly offers tiered subscriptions, providing more flexibility in content pricing.
Payout Frequency21 days after payment7 days after paymentFansly offers faster access to earnings compared to OnlyFans.
Support ServicesSlower due to large user baseMore responsive, especially on social mediaFansly’s support is more agile and responsive, partly due to its smaller size.
Unique FeaturesStrong brand recognitionTiered subscriptions, free follower option, custom emojisFansly provides additional features like free followers and custom emojis for content teasing.
Potential EarningsStronger brand recognition, easier promotionGrowing popularity, but requires more explanation to potential subscribersOnlyFans leads in brand recognition, which can aid in attracting subscribers.
Brand RecognitionVery highGrowing, but less than OnlyFansOnlyFans is more widely known compared to Fansly.
Content ProtectionAutomatic watermarking, geoblockingAutomatic watermarking, geoblockingBoth platforms offer similar content protection features.
Community SupportLarger subreddit communitySmaller, but active subreddit communityOnlyFans has a larger online community presence, but Fansly’s is actively growing.

Ease of Use

When evaluating the ease of use of a subscriber website, it’s crucial to consider both the creators’ and the users’ experiences.

A platform is ineffective if it’s packed with features for creators but fails to resonate with users. Conversely, a user-friendly site that’s cumbersome for creators to upload and manage content is equally problematic.

So, how do OnlyFans and Fansly stack up in terms of user experience? The truth is, they’re quite similar, a recurring theme you’ll notice throughout this guide. From a user’s standpoint, both platforms have a similar look and functionality.

A common critique of OnlyFans is its user-unfriendliness for browsing different creators and models. Unfortunately, Fansly doesn’t significantly improve in this area either.

Both platforms seem to be designed more for creators to promote their profiles via direct links on other social media platforms, rather than facilitating discovery within their own site.

From a creator’s perspective, the two are also comparable, though some users on Reddit and other forums suggest that Fansly might be slightly more intuitive and cleaner in design.

However, neither platform is a standout in terms of user experience. They meet the basic needs of users and creators, but there’s room for improvement. While OnlyFans may not be inclined to make significant changes, given its current success, it will be interesting to see if Fansly makes enhancements to compete with other platforms.

Result: It’s a close call, with Fansly slightly ahead, but not enough to declare a clear winner in the usability department.

Making Money

The primary revenue model for both OnlyFans and Fansly involves charging for access to content. Creators can set a subscription fee for viewing their photos and videos, or charge for direct messaging. Additionally, receiving tips is another way for creators to earn.

However, this is where the simplicity ends. Unlike some of their competitors, neither OnlyFans nor Fansly currently offer options like a merchandise store or the sale of access to private social feeds.

One noteworthy feature of Fansly is its tiered subscription system. Creators can set different price points for access to varying levels of content, such as charging more for longer videos. This tiered approach offers flexibility but can also mean more management work for creators. Many prefer a single-tier system for its simplicity.

Result: Fansly edges out OnlyFans with its tiered subscription model.

Potential Earnings

The financial model for both platforms is similar: creators set a subscription fee, and the platform takes a 20% cut, applicable to both subscriptions and any additional earnings like tips or direct messages. This is another area where Fansly mirrors OnlyFans.

The potential earnings largely depend on the number of subscribers a creator can attract. OnlyFans has an advantage due to its more established brand. Mentioning an OnlyFans subscription is almost self-explanatory, suggesting exclusive, potentially more intimate content.

On the other hand, prompting someone to subscribe to Fansly might require additional explanation, as it’s less known. The more explanation required, the harder it can be to make a sale.

As for ‘findability’ or the chance of being discovered by casual site browsers, neither platform excels. However, OnlyFans currently has the upper hand due to its brand recognition, which can aid in growing a subscriber base. This advantage could shift if OnlyFans decides to pivot away from NSFW content in the future.

Result: OnlyFans, courtesy of its stronger brand recognition.

Payout Frequencies

OnlyFans processes payouts for creators 21 days after payment is received from users. Once the money is in the creator’s account, they can withdraw it any time, as long as they’ve hit the minimum threshold of $20.

Fansly, on the other hand, offers a quicker payout. Your earnings are available just 7 days after payment, a reduction from the previous 10 days, indicating their commitment to improving services. Originally set at a $100 payout limit, Fansly has also reduced this to $20, aligning with OnlyFans.

Result: Fansly

Assessing the Best Features

In terms of features, neither OnlyFans nor Fansly is a clear leader. Other platforms may offer more diversity in functionalities and a better overall user experience. However, Fansly is making strides to catch up.

Both platforms are primarily subscription-based, allowing charging for access to photos and videos, tips, and direct messaging. They also automatically watermark content, which is crucial for IP protection.

OnlyFans has long offered geoblocking, a feature allowing creators to block certain geographical areas from accessing their content – ideal for maintaining anonymity. Fansly added this feature in 2021.

Regarding community support, both platforms have dedicated subreddits, with OnlyFans having a larger subscriber base. However, Fansly’s following is still substantial and offers good promotional opportunities for creators.

  • OnlyFans: The platform’s main strength lies in its brand recognition, rather than exclusive features.
  • Fansly: It stands out with its tiered subscription model, allowing for charging different rates for various content levels. A popular feature is the option for free followers, where creators can post free content to entice subscriptions. Custom emojis to cover parts of images for free followers, revealing the full content upon subscription, add a playful element to the platform. Fansly is also actively working on introducing more features, as indicated by their social media updates.

Result Fansly, for its innovative approach and ongoing efforts to add new functionalities.

Support Services: OnlyFans vs. Fansly

OnlyFans boasts a robust support network on their website, emphasizing their readiness to assist their community. However, the experience for creators seeking help might not always align with these claims.

Fansly’s website, on the other hand, presents some challenges in navigation, especially for those needing assistance but not yet registered. The platform primarily directs to email support for unregistered users, complemented by a limited selection of FAQs that are somewhat hard to locate.

Despite these initial hurdles, Fansly shines in actual support for its creators. The smaller size of Fansly compared to OnlyFans plays a role here. OnlyFans’ large user base and popularity mean they often struggle to keep up with support demands, leading to longer response times – sometimes up to a week.

Fansly, while experiencing its own growth-related challenges, offers effective support through social media channels. It’s worth noting that they operate multiple accounts, with their main account being more responsive than their official support account. Questions posed on their social media typically receive swift responses.

Fansly’s approach to support is marked by transparency and a clear effort to manage the demands of a rapidly expanding user base.

Result: Fansly takes the lead, thanks to its more responsive and honest approach to handling creator support issues.

Deciding Between OnlyFans and Fansly: Which is the Better Choice?

OnlyFans boasts a well-known brand, an undeniable advantage for creators. However, Fansly is rapidly emerging as a strong competitor, particularly appealing to those just starting their journey or those concerned about OnlyFans’ future stance on NSFW content.

Notably, many prominent NSFW content creators have switched to Fansly and are vocal about their positive experiences.

While the allure of a big-name platform like OnlyFans is tempting, especially for marketing to existing social media followers, Fansly is making significant strides in adding and improving features at a faster pace.

However, it’s important to remember that these aren’t your only options. There are other platforms out there offering a richer array of features and diverse ways to monetize your fanbase. For those interested in exploring these alternatives, you can find them here.

Rate this article

More Tips & Special Offers?

Subtribe to our newsletter for more Reddit marketing tips, and exclusive Upvote.Shop Panel offers & deals.